Archive for January 3rd, 2023

TFSA Overcontribution: Relying on Information in Your CRA Online Account

Posted on:

One challenge when relying on CRA-provided information online in respect of TFSA contribution room is that the information is not updated on a real-time basis due to the delay in receiving information from TFSA issuers. Although CRA has many disclaimers surrounding this issue, some individuals may be unaware or misinterpret their comments.

A July 14, 2022 Financial Post article (Taxpayer relying on CRA website info gets hit with penalty for contributing too much to TFSA, Jamie Golombek) indicated that financial institutions are required to submit information on all contributions and withdrawals for each calendar year by the end of February of the following year. CRA may not process and update this information until April or later. As such, for example, the contribution room available online in  January 2022, would likely only consider transactions from 2020 and earlier, with the 2021 transactions only being included later in the Spring of 2022.

In a June 15, 2022 Federal Court case, the Court addressed an application for judicial review of  CRA’s decision to deny relief for taxes on excess TFSA contributions (1%/month for each month the TFSA is  overcontributed) where a taxpayer misunderstood the contribution room as published online in CRA’s My Account.

In 2019, the taxpayer contributed a total of $26,002, while her contribution room was only $7,849, resulting in a penalty tax of$1,784. Only $400 of interest income was earned on the overcontribution. The taxpayer made contributions in January and February 2019 based on what the taxpayer misinterpreted to be her contribution room at  that particular point in time, resulting in an over-contribution. The taxpayer argued she did not intend to make an over-contribution and that the information on MyAccount was “very confusing” and gave rise to a reasonable error.

The taxpayer previously made excess contributions which were withdrawn after correspondence was received from CRA. It appeared that CRA assessed no excess contributions tax at that time.

Taxpayer loses
While the Court was sympathetic to the taxpayer’s position, in the self-reporting tax system in Canada, individuals are responsible for understanding their TFSA accounts, and thus the Court ruled that CRA was reasonable in denying relief to the taxpayer.

Had this been the taxpayer’s first excess contribution, the result may have been different as CRA generally offers a little more relief in such situations. 

ACTION: Do not rely solely on the information presented in your online CRA account.  Additional verification should be conducted to ensure that recent contributions have been incorporated into the contribution room number. If you discover you have accidentally contributed too much, the excess should be withdrawn without delay to minimize exposure to this punitive tax.

* = required field